I put on The Days expecting a pleasant half hour and ended up giving it most of an evening, which says something about the length that I’ll get to in a minute. Nathaniel Sutton took three years over this record, and sixteen songs later you can hear the time in how steadily it holds one temperature: warm, slightly bruised, always glancing over its own shoulder. The subject is growing up and whatever is left of it after the people and places have gone elsewhere, a theme that has sunk more albums than it has saved, and he gets around the usual traps by writing like someone who remembers the particulars rather than the idea of remembering.
What keeps the nostalgia from curdling is that Sutton seems as interested in the awkward parts as the golden ones. Adolescence in these songs comes with its embarrassments attached, and love and loss are handled at roughly the same size as everything else, which spares the record the inflated sense of tragedy that haunts this kind of writing. Looking back is the whole premise, yet the album rarely sounds stuck there.
The arrangements split between full-band rooms thick with atmosphere and bare corners where there is mostly a guitar and a voice, and the division is handled with more care than I expected. Records built this way often feel like two EPs stapled together, with a coin toss deciding the order. Here the quiet songs seem to grow out of the loud ones, as if the band had gone home and the house was still ringing. Stay With Me is the clearest example, a folk-leaning acoustic piece that lets you lie down for a few minutes without ever feeling like a rest stop, and I suspect it’s the track many people will end up putting on in the background of their evenings.
There is also a real pop instinct in the writing, and it shows most plainly when a guest arrives. 1995, with Ellie Heath, is the most commercial song on the record and the one I would play for a friend who asked what the album sounds like but didn’t want a lecture; it is glossy, immediately likeable, and still willing to sit inside the awkwardness of being a teenager rather than sanding it off. Some indie listeners get nervous when a song sounds this ready for radio, and for what it’s worth I would take a hook written with that much confidence over a mumble dressed up as depth. The guest list overall stays small, which keeps the whole thing sounding like his record rather than a compilation of friends.
My favorite is Vintage Glow, and most of what I like about it is borrowed, in the best sense: there is some U2 in the way it builds and some Depeche Mode in how it carries its sadness without raising its voice, so a listener of a certain age will feel recognized before the second chorus arrives. The song wears these influences the way a person wears a family accent, never like a tribute act, and the piano gives it a center that the references alone couldn’t supply. If the album needs a single song to explain its mood to a stranger, I would hand over this one before any other.
Sixteen songs ask for more patience than most people spend on one album these days, and I will admit the stretch in the middle tested mine. A few gestures recur often enough (the wistful opening line, the glowing chord change, the gentle swell) that some tracks blur together if you play the whole thing straight through. I am still reluctant to complain loudly, because the effort is visible in every arrangement and the sheer volume of material suggests someone who refused to cut anything that mattered to him, and I sympathize with that even when the editor in me doesn’t. For anyone who tends to drift during long records, Back When is the one worth flagging, since it rewards attention and keeps the whole from sagging.
Sleepover is where that turn happens for me, and it hit harder than anything else on the record, a real revelation after a lot of well-made nostalgia. It is also the reason the closing piano ballad Threshold lands as personally as it does: without Sleepover it would be a graceful ending, and with it the last song sounds like a person finally talking about what comes next in his own plain voice, hopeful without hedging. After fifteen songs of looking back, the optimism has somewhere to come from.
This one is for people who like their nostalgia with a pulse: listeners who came for the polish of 1995 and don’t mind staying for the quieter material, anyone with a soft spot for piano in a minor key, and the kind of person who enjoys an album that takes its time getting where it’s going. It isn’t a record for anyone chasing risk, noise or a sharp left turn, and nothing about it pretends otherwise. For an artist at this stage, three years of work that holds together across sixteen songs is a solid argument for paying attention to whatever Sutton does next.
Published in partnership with SubmitHub
